last weekend i went to a dance with some friends. a member of our party was nervous about attending, about whether he’d feel welcomed and comfortable. during the nervous laughter about what possible hostilities might look like, these words fell out of my mouth: “watch, they’ll all be really blasé and accepting and you’ll be disappointed.”
that threw some cold water on the conversation and we left shortly after that.
why’d i say that? why did i imply that my friend was creating some needless drama with his defensiveness? that’s complicated. he’s trans, and going through female-to-male transition. we were going to a womens’ dance. (not, however, a women-only dance.)
there were mostly women there, as well as some men and transfolk, and a refreshingly wide range of ages. i don’t intend to idealize queer women’s communities, especially white ones. we have got some problems. racism, ableism, classism, alcoholism and transphobia spring to mind. but still, i enjoy dyke-focussed space, and it’s a rare thing in my life. i like seeing reflections of myself and my subculture, i like the increased feeling of safety when i’m surrounded by mostly women (enough to change out of my sweaty longjohns in a corner of a very crowded venue when the washroom lineup is dauntingly long) and l like the sense of celebration and collaborative mischief.
as a white, slim, and attractive able-bodied queer, my trans friend probably valued women-and-dyke-focussed space for similar reasons at one time. now much of that has shifted. he does not want to be read as female and has taken deliberate steps to irrevocably change his body. this complicates his navigation of dyke space in many ways, more ways than i can address in one post. with his new, growing male privilege he loses his automatic passport to womens’ spaces. he might be read as a dyke, as a tranny, as biologically male. he could be misread, invisible, welcomed as one of many genderqueers, cruised by a fag. he could be viewed as a threat. i had a friend who was beaten by transphobic dykes in a canadian city a few years ago. it happens. i’m not surprised that guys sometimes get a bit defensive at the prospect of entering women-focussed space – even with their dyke friends, at a mixed event, where gender fluidity and trans bodies are loudly celebrated onstage during the amateurish-but-earnest opening drag king show.
so why did i interject my snarky remark? maybe i’m tired of the way they say “LLLLesbian dance” with the derisively drawn-out L (and you know why they say lesbian, not dyke.) maybe it’s that familiar thing of generating negativity about a place when it’s no longer home. when it’s time to leave, all the flaws are highlighted. how shallow, how petty, how small-minded and trite LLLLesbianville was. how boring and stale. i couldn’t have coped with one more Indigo Girls song, could you?
…me? not only am i a dyke, i was also presenting femme that night, and i guess i developed some defensiveness all my own.
it is too easy for a transman’s legitimate frustrations with the shortcomings of dyke communities to morph into good old-fashioned sexism and bigotry. i have witnessed this, been silenced by this, been a target of this, in various ways for the last decade since my first girlfriend came out as a guy. i kind of understand this. but it’s a shit way to keep allies.
i will accompany you to the washroom, happily dance with you all night, remember your pronoun preference, help to educate others, share my knowledge of acupuncture and herbalism to smooth your transition and recovery from surgeries, and let you know that i think you’re just as hot with facial hair and a flat chest as you were when you passed as female full time. my affection for my friends, and my level of pain and anger about the violence done to trans bodies i’ve loved is such that i will fight alongside you on the street if necessary. i am open to ongoing conversations with you about what you might want or need from an ally. but i want these conversations to be two-way. just to point out the obvious – LLLLesbianville, with all its flaws, remains one of my homes. fractal truth: i need allies and respect too.